China gene-edited child experiment 'could have created unintended mutations'

Laverne Higgins
December 5, 2019

Experts said yesterday that the gene-editing that Jiankui claimed was meant to provide long-life protection against HIV infection might have failed in its objective and introduced unwanted, "off-target" mutations.

In November 2018, biophysicist He Jiankui told the world that he had successfully edited the genes of two newborn twin girls, named Lulu and Nana, modifying their CCR5 gene to make them resistant to HIV.

Excerpts from the manuscript were released by the MIT Technology Review for the goal of showing how Chinese biophysicist He Jiankui ignored ethical and scientific norms in creating the twins Lula and Nana, whose birth in late 2018 sent shockwaves through the scientific world.

Effective July 2018, access to full reports will only be available with a subscription.

Several scientists have claimed that He's research and claims on the variant gene of CCR5 is inaccurate and a blatant misinterpretation of the actual data. "The statement that embryo editing will help millions is equal parts delusional and outrageous".

"Approaching this document, I was hoping to see a reflective and mindful approach to gene editing in human embryos".

While He's team targeted the right gene, scientists say that He was not able to replicate the required variation of "Delta 35".The scientific community says that the researchers in the project made "off-target" edits.

Leaders Didn't Mock Trump — Fox Hosts
Canadian Prime Minister Justin Trudeau and other foreign leaders are caught on camera apparently talking candidly about U.S. Trudeau has yet to apologize for the comments, and insists he and Trump have a "good and constructive relationship".


Using Crispr in humans is controversial as it sometimes causes unplanned gene edits.

Here, the researchers claimed they had searched for such effects in the early-stage embryos and found just one - but this glossed over the fact that it would be impossible to carry out a comprehensive search without inspecting each of the embryo's cells and thus destroying it.

Further ethical concerns included that the parents of the babies might have wanted to take part for the wrong reasons.

Jeanne O'Brien, a reproductive endocrinologist at Shady Grove Fertility told the MIT Technology Review that there are speculations that the lack of access to the fertility centers prompted the parents to be involved in the experiment despite the many risks to the children.

The daddy was HIV optimistic, which carries a major social stigma in China and makes it virtually unimaginable to have entry to fertility therapy, although a well-established method generally known as "sperm washing" prevents the an infection being handed to unborn youngsters.

Moreover, the scientists noted that He failed to include the names of the twins' fertility doctors, as well as the doctor who delivered them.

Dr He's manuscript used to be submitted to journals in conjunction with Nature and the Journal of the American Medical Association, nonetheless has no longer been officially published.

Other reports by

Discuss This Article

FOLLOW OUR NEWSPAPER